Head to head

Volkswagen ID.4 vs smart #3

A side-by-side comparison of published Australian specifications, including WLTP range figures.

This comparison is generated automatically from published manufacturer specifications, not from hands-on testing. It sets the two cars' figures side by side; it is not a road test.

Car A

Volkswagen ID.4 electric car photographed from the front three-quarter angle, 420 km of range

Volkswagen ID.4

From A$79,950 Β· 420 km

Read the Volkswagen ID.4 review

Car B

smart #3 electric car photographed from the front three-quarter angle, 425 km of range

smart #3

From A$77,900 Β· 425 km

Read the smart #3 review

The verdict

The smart #3 offers more range β€” 425 km WLTP against 420 km, a gap of about 10 km between charges. The Volkswagen ID.4 is the better fit for families needing extra boot space, with 543 litres and 5 seats versus 370 litres and 5 in the smart #3. On price the smart #3 starts about A$2,050 lower, while the quicker of the two off the line is the smart #3 at 5.8s.

On the measured specifications below, the Volkswagen ID.4 leads in 2 areas and the smart #3 in 3.

Specs side by side

Price from (new)(Lower is better)

Volkswagen ID.4A$79,950
smart #3A$77,900

Range (WLTP)

Volkswagen ID.4420 km
smart #3425 km

Battery

Volkswagen ID.477 kWh
smart #366 kWh

Body type

Volkswagen ID.4SUV
smart #3SUV

Seats

Volkswagen ID.45
smart #35

Boot space

Volkswagen ID.4543 litres
smart #3370 litres

0–100 km/h(Lower is better)

Volkswagen ID.46.7s
smart #35.8s

Standout feature

Volkswagen ID.4Big boot and long range for family duty
smart #3Coupe-SUV with Mercedes-designed interior

How they score

Each attribute is a percentile against every EV on sale in Australia β€” 100 means best in the dataset. These are the same attributes our recommender uses.

Range

Volkswagen ID.433/100
smart #338/100

Price

Volkswagen ID.471/100
smart #375/100

Family space

Volkswagen ID.481/100
smart #316/100

Performance

Volkswagen ID.427/100
smart #353/100

Tech

Volkswagen ID.44/100
smart #322/100

Other comparisons